Water Heater Replacement in New Jersey

Carmine P Aumenta & Sons provides water heater replacement across Mendham, Morristown, Basking Ridge, Jersey City, Hoboken, and surrounding NJ communities.

Call (201) 451-8008
  • Restored reliable hot water for your household's daily demand
  • Proper sizing matched to your home's layout and number of occupants
  • Safe removal and disposal of the old unit with no mess left behind
  • Connections and venting checked to current NJ code before job completion
  • Reduced energy use compared to an aging, sediment-laden tank
  • Lower risk of water damage from a corroded or leaking unit
A licensed plumber from Carmine P Aumenta & Sons installing a new water heater in a basement utility room in Mendham, NJ. The old unit has been removed and the new tank is connected to gas supply and venting lines.

Expert Water Heater Replacement in New Jersey

When your water heater stops performing, Carmine P Aumenta & Sons Plumbing & Heating Inc. handles full water heater replacement for homeowners across Morris, Somerset, Union, and Hudson counties. We serve communities from Mendham and Bernardsville to Jersey City and Hoboken. Many homes in this region, from older colonials in Morristown and Madison to established neighborhoods in Summit and Westfield, have utility spaces with tight clearances, aging shutoffs, and venting setups that require careful review before any new unit goes in. Our process starts with a full assessment of your current setup, including fuel type, available space, and household hot water demand. We remove the old unit, make all connections to current code, and confirm proper venting and operation before we leave. Whether your unit is leaking, failing to heat, or simply past its service life, we give you a clear picture of your options. Call Carmine P Aumenta & Sons to schedule your water heater replacement.

What's included

  • Restored reliable hot water for your household's daily demand
  • Proper sizing matched to your home's layout and number of occupants
  • Safe removal and disposal of the old unit with no mess left behind
  • Connections and venting checked to current NJ code before job completion
  • Reduced energy use compared to an aging, sediment-laden tank
  • Lower risk of water damage from a corroded or leaking unit
Family-Owned Since 1977
Free Estimates
Third-Generation Operators
Emergency Service Available
Multi-County Coverage
Licensed & Insured

Need this service?

Get a clear roof assessment before you commit.

Call Now

Water Heater Replacement FAQ

Common questions about water heater replacement in New Jersey.

Replacement is usually the right call when your unit is leaking from the tank, producing rust-colored water, or has a history of repeated failures. We assess the age and condition of your unit at your Morristown or Mendham home and give you a straight answer.

Yes, we work in homes throughout Bernardsville, Madison, and Westfield where utility spaces are compact and access requires planning. We review clearances, the removal path, and venting before any work begins.

We replace gas and electric water heaters across our full service area, including Summit, New Providence, and Basking Ridge. Our team evaluates your existing fuel source and connection setup before recommending a replacement unit.

We remove and dispose of the old unit as part of the replacement service. Homeowners in Cranford, Scotch Plains, and Springfield do not need to arrange separate disposal.

Yes, we replace water heaters in older and multi-family properties throughout Jersey City, Hoboken, and Bayonne. These buildings often have specific venting and access conditions we account for during the job.

Rust-colored hot water, a unit that runs out of hot water faster than it used to, visible tank corrosion, or an active leak are all reasons to call us. Homeowners across Randolph, Florham Park, and Chester contact us when they notice these warning signs.

Still have questions?

Call us directly. Real answers, no scripts.

Call (201) 451-8008

What our customers say.

4.8
207 Google reviews

Worked with us?

Leave a Review

My family has called on Aumenta Plumbing for years! And they have always provide excellent service. In June, we had to have a toilet replaced and a kitchen faucet installed. They discovered during the toilet replacement, that one of our old pipes had been decaying. They were able to include that repair on the same day. Then more recently, we needed our bathtub unclogged and they came right away. My family and I are so glad that Carmine's sons have continued the business and the level of service quality that their father provided. Highly recommend!

Catherina Mirasol Google review · July 2026

As the owner of a historic single family home in Jersey City, since 2014, I have turned to Ben and his family for all my plumbing needs— from boiler maintenance to major work and even emergencies. This family run business has always been there with top quality work and professionalism. I highly recommend Aumenta.

Elizabeth Houlton Google review · June 2026

Ben Aumenta handled our job, everything with our hot water heather replacement job was quick and clear. We had an issue with the exhaust pipe on our previous hot water heater so Ben made sure he could fit us in asap to replace the whole set up. He also noticed that the condensation pipe from our HVAC system was dropped on an angle that would make draining difficult and he propped it up for us even though we hadn't hired him for the HVAC. Great attention to detail and care for the customer, we're really happy. Communication from Aumenta was excellent - email and text notifications when the estimate was scheduled as well as when the install was happening, so we always knew what to expect. We'd definitely recommend them!

Melissa Romo Google review · July 2026

Absolutely outstanding service from start to finish! From the very first call, the receptionist was professional, prompt, and genuinely sweet. She made what could have been a stressful situation feel completely effortless. Even though we called last minute, they kindly squeezed us into their schedule and were true to their word on the arrival time. Our plumber from Carmine P. Aumenta & Sons Plumbing-Heating was an absolute pleasure — kind, knowledgeable, and incredibly efficient. He got the job done quickly while making us feel completely at ease. This is exactly how a family business should operate: with warmth, expertise, and total reliability. They are most certainly making their late father proud. We will happily call Carmine P. Aumenta & Sons for any future plumbing or heating needs. Highly, highly recommend!

Kristina Google review · June 2026

My sister recommended Aumenra Plumbing to me last year. I had them come and replace my hot water heater and repair an issue with my furnace. They were efficient and reasonably priced. I called them this year to replace the connection for my garden hose and then to add a water line for my washing machine. I am more than pleased with their work and recommend them highly.

Hellen G Google review · May 2026

Call, or book online — we're always nearby when you need us.

Hours

  • Monday 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
  • Tuesday 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
  • Wednesday 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
  • Thursday 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
  • Friday 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
  • Saturday Closed
  • Sunday Closed
Carmine P Aumenta & Sons Plumbing & Heating Inc. logo